China's Origins: Ancient Legends and Modern Archaeology

Legends, ca. 100 BCE

Cultural heroes

Fuxi (Subduer of Animals)

Nüwa (Mother of Humanity)

Shen Nong (Divine Farmer)

Yellow Emperor

*The Three Sage Kings:

Yao
Shun
Yu

The Three Dynasties

*Xia (?)

Trad. 2200-1766 BCE

*Shang

1554—1046 BCE (Li Feng)

ca. 1600—1045 BCE (Hansen)

*Zhou (1045-256 BCE)

Only historical dynasty by 1900

Archaeological Record of Early Complex Societies

*Erlitou, Ca. 1900-1550 BCE

Near Luoyang in W. Henan

Map of site

5 sq. kilometers

Population 18-30,000 at height around 1700

Few Burials

One large tomb empty except for dog skeleton

Scattered small-scale burial sites

Some with rich grave goods

Turquoise dragon and bronze bell, burial no. 3

Monumental buildings

20+ foundations

"Palace" #1 foundation, 16th c. BCE

108 x100 meters

Pounded earth foundation (hangtu)

Workshops

Pottery and bone manufacturing sites

Large-scale bronze works

2 dozen vessels and a few bells and weapons

Foundry covering 10,000 sq meters

Casting technology

Bronze Metallurgy

Controversies over origins

Longshan Sites, 2600-2000 BCE

Copper objects

Seima-Turbino Culture, 2200-1700 BCE

Cast bronze spearheads

Illustration of bronze spearheads and Map

Qijia Culture in Gansu ca. 2000 BCE

350 sites yielding 50 small objects

Is Erlitou the capital of a "state"? Capital of the Xia Dynasty?

"Xia" dynasty, Trad. 2200-1766 BCE

Settlements within 200 km of Erlitou

Similar material culture

Lack large bronzes

Potential suppliers of resources

Millet for food supplies

Timber for house building

Charcoal for fuel to make bronzes

Kaolin for elite white ceramics

Metal for making bronzes

Pebbles for palace foundations

Salt for diet

Hansen, 19-34; Xu Hong, “Chap. 15: Erlitou Culture” PERMALINK

1. Where does Hansen begin Chinese history?

2. How does Xu interpret Erlitou society based on the burials?

3. How does Xu interpret the foundations of buildings?

3. How does Xu explain the origins of bronze metallurgy in China?

What is the significance of the casting technique, according to Xu and Hansen?

How does the quality of Erlitou bronze objects compare to later ones at Shang Anyang? (Hansen pp. 32-34)

4. Does Xu agree with the interpretation that Erlitou was the capital of the Xia Dynasty? Why or why not?

Archaeological Puzzles

Erlitou (Xia?) decline 1600-1500 BCE

Erligang (Shang?) rise at Zhengzhou

Rapidly expands beyond Erlitou culture

*Erligang (Shang?) culture

Yanshi, founded, ca. 1500 BCE

6 km east of Erlitou

Theories

1st Erligang capital

Garrison to guard (Xia) Erlitou

Zhengzhou, C. Henan ca. 1600-1400 BCE

20 sq. km vs. Erlitou 5 sq. km

Urban layout

City walls

Inner is 7 km

Palaces

Graveyards

Organized

Human sacrifice

Workshops

Bronze, Bone, Pottery

Bronze production

Dwarfs Erlitou (and Near East)

427 pieces of clay molds excavated

35% tool molds

Pickaxes, axes, awls, fishhooks

11% weapon molds

Adzes, dagger-axes, knives, arrowheads

17 % vessel molds

Remainder unknown

Erligang Expansion?

Erligang, Zhengzhou, Henan vs. Panlongcheng, Hubei

Similar bronze vessel types

Different pottery

What possible explanations are there for the similarities in bronze vessel design and differences in pottery?

Erligang (Zhengzhou) Retreat, ca. 1300 BCE

Regional bronze styles emerge

Military expansion and retreat?

Interstate trade?

Bagley thesis

Transition from imperial unity to interacting regional states