Nation Building and Rebuilding: Iraq

Iraq

Population

28 million

Ethnicity

Arab 75%-80%

Kurdish 15%-20%

Turkoman, Assyrian or other 5%

Religion

Muslim 97%

Shi'ite 60%-65%

Sunni 32%-37%

Christian or other 3%

British colonialism

World War I

British invasion

Military occupation, 1916-20

*British Mandate of Mesopotamia, 1920-32

Nationalism

Political instability, 1932-68

Constitutional monarchy, 1921-58

King Faisal, r. 1921-33

Weak son and grandson, 1933-1958

Nationalist revolution and governments, 1958-68

Series of coups

*Ba'th (Revival) Party Rule, 1968-2003

5,000 members 1968

Dictatorship

Nazi and Leninist techniques

Secular nationalism

*Saddam Hussein, "President," 1979-2003

Political stability

Personal loyalties

Tikrit connections

Intimidation

Economic development

Oil wealth, 1970s

Literacy rate, 2000 est.

Overall: 74.1%

male: 84.1%

female: 64.2%

Foreign policy

Alliance with the Soviet Union

Nationalistic border claims over oil-rich territory

War with Iran 1980-88

Soviet and U. S. support

Invasion of Kuwait, Aug. 1990

Colonial border claims

U.S.-Iraq Conflict

Gulf War, Jan.-Feb. 1991

U.S. Motives

Territorial rights of Kuwait

Oil supplies of Kuwait and Saudi Arabia

International support

U.N. Security Council

Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Syria, etc.

Powell doctrine

George H. W. Bush and Brent Scrowcroft. A World Transformed. New York: Vintage, 1999, p. 489:

"Trying to eliminate Saddam, extending the ground war into an occupation of Iraq …would have incurred incalculable human and political costs...We would have been forced to occupy Baghdad and, in effect, rule Iraq. The coalition would instantly have collapsed, the Arabs deserting it in anger...there was no viable 'exit strategy' we could see...Had we gone the invasion route, the United States could conceivably still be an occupying power in a bitterly hostile land."

U.S. invasion, 2003

Theories about Bush administration decision

Panic?

9/11 and “War on Terror”

Poor or misjudged intelligence?

Weapons of mass destruction

Warm reception

Economic gain?

Oil supplies

Psychology?

Father-Son competition

U.S. Motives

Unclear

International support

Mainly European

U.N. Security Council opposed

Arab countries opposed

“Rumsfeld doctrine”

Invasion, 3/19

145,000 ground forces

Capture of Baghdad, 4/9

U.S. occupation, 2003-present

Liberators or occupiers?

Inadequate planning for occupation

Gen. Eric Shinseki’s estimate of occupation troops

“Several hundred thousand”

Looting, April 2003

De-Ba'thification, May 2003

Intensified violence

Anti-American insurgency

4000+ U.S. Military Deaths (Monthly Statistics)

Chart

Iraqi civil war

Religious and ethnic violence

Sunni Arabs, Shi’ite Arabs, Kurds

Personalistic politics

Militias

Criminal gangs

Iraqi Civilian Deaths, 2003-present

Record keepers?

100,000-660,000 depending on estimate

Iraqi Refugees

2.3 million in 2007

8% of population

World's 3rd largest after Afghanistan!

(For current figures, see U.N. High Commission for Refugees "Country Operations Profile: Iraq")

Jordan and Syria

Iraq Governing Authorities

Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA)

April 2003-June 2004

Paul Bremmer

Iraq Interim and Transitional Governments

June 2004-May 2006

Iraq constitution approved, Oct. 2005

Iraqi government elected

May 2006-present

Study Questions-Lecture

1. How did British colonialism encourage political instability and authoritarianism in Iraq?

2. How did Saddam Hussein bring stability to Iraqi politics? How did his foreign policy contribute to his demise?

3. How did American planning for the first Gulf War in 1991 differ from the invasion of Iraq in 2003? Why did the American invasion of Iraq in 2003 destabilize Iraq?

Study Questions-Reading

Hansen 952-8

1. How did media depictions of the fall of Saddam Hussein's statue in Baghdad differ in America, Europe and the Middle East? What explains the differences? Did the U.S. media serve the interests of the American people?

Web Reading: Riverbend, "Baghdad Burning," 8/1/03-8/31/03

1. What is Riverbend's background?

2. What social and public safety problems does Riverbend describe in Iraq in August 2003? Why was it impossible for her to continue working after the U.S. invasion?

3. What are Riverbend's opinions of President George W. Bush, the U.S. Coalition Provisional Authority governing Iraq under Paul Bremmer, American troops posted in Baghdad, and Iraqi politicians who cooperate with them? Do you think that she is being fair?